Navigating complex insurance issues in personal injury litigation

March 21, 2025
husband and wife angry with navigating complex insurance issues
(Photo Credit: fizkes/Shutterstock)

Personal injury litigation often involves navigating a maze of insurance-related issues. From determining available coverage to negotiating with multiple insurers, understanding the intricacies of insurance law is crucial. Clients may face obstacles such as policy exclusions, coverage disputes and subrogation claims. Attorneys need to approach these cases strategically and with a firm grasp of insurance complexities. This can make the difference between a fair settlement and an inadequate recovery.

Types of coverage

Several types of insurance policies may come into play in personal injury litigation:

  • Auto insurance: Covers injuries from car accidents, including liability, uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) coverage and personal injury protection (PIP) or medical payments (MedPay).
  • Homeowners insurance: May provide coverage for accidents on the insured’s property, such as slip-and-fall injuries or dog bites.
  • Umbrella policies: May offer  additional liability protection beyond standard auto or homeowners coverage.
  • Health insurance: Often covers medical expenses related to the injury but may involve reimbursement claims through subrogation.

Identifying all applicable coverages ensures that injured parties receive the maximum compensation available.

Dealing with multiple insurers

When multiple insurers are involved, attorneys must strategically coordinate their clients’ claims to avoid delays and denials. Key strategies include, but are not limited to:

  • Understanding policy prioritization: Determining which insurer is primarily responsible for covering damages.
  • Coordinating claims effectively: Providing consistent information to all insurers while avoiding contradictions that could jeopardize coverage.
  • Challenging denials: Insurers may dispute liability or coverage, requiring legal intervention to enforce policyholder rights.

Successfully managing multiple insurers requires persistence and a keen understanding of policy language.

Subrogation and liens 

Subrogation and lien claims can significantly impact a plaintiff’s final recovery:

  • Subrogation rights: If a health insurer or workers’ compensation carrier pays medical bills, they may seek reimbursement from the injury settlement.
  • Medical liens: Hospitals and healthcare providers may place liens on a settlement to recover unpaid medical expenses.
  • Negotiation tactics: Attorneys may be able to negotiate reduced lien payments to ensure the client retains a fair portion of the settlement.

Failing to address these claims properly can leave plaintiffs with less compensation than expected.

Insurance issues in personal injury litigation are complex and require careful navigation. Understanding policy coverages, managing multiple insurers and effectively handling subrogation and liens are critical to maximizing client recovery. Legal professionals must be well-versed in insurance law to advocate effectively for their clients.


Contact Info

Name(Required)

Practice Info

By submitting information to LegaFi Law LLC, you agree that the information you submit, including your phone number and email address, will be shared with and used by LegaFi Law LLC (an Arizona law firm), www.legafi.com, 888-4-LegaFi, and their agents to contact you. You understand that this authorization overrides any previous registrations on any federal or state Do Not Call registry(ies). Please do not share any confidential or privileged information through this website. LegaFi or their agent(s) may be ordered by a court of law to produce your information in certain legal situations.
Opt In to Receive Calls, Text Messages, and Emails
By checking this box, I consent to receive from LegaFi Law LLC, their agents, or their co-counsel, marketing emails, calls, or texts sent by automatic telephone dialing systems or otherwise. I understand that this authorization overrides any registrations on any Do Not Call registry(ies). I understand that consent is not a condition of purchase and that I may opt out at any time. Review LegaFi's Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy here
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


After you fill out the form, an attorney(s) or their agent(s) may contact you to discuss your legal rights.

ATTORNEY ADVERTISING

The choice of a lawyer is an important decision and should not be based solely on advertisements.

ATTORNEY ADVERTISEMENT: THIS WEB PAGE IS AN ADVERTISEMENT. The information contained herein is not legal advice. Any information you submit to LegaFi Law LLC does not create an attorney-client relationship and may not be protected by attorney-client privilege. Instead, your information will be forwarded to an attorney(s) or their agent(s) for the purpose of a confidential review and potential representation if you qualify. You will only be contacted by an attorney(s) or their agent(s) in response to your inquiry if your initial information appears to qualify you for representation. If you are not contacted by an attorney(s) or their agent(s) within one week, sending you a signed engagement letter, you should consult another firm since all legal claims are subject to filing deadlines. All photos on this website are stock art and do not depict clients. This website is governed by the Arizona Rules of Professional Conduct.